Gear-obsessed editors choose every product we review. We may earn commission if you buy from a link. Why Trust Us?
Iron and steel may be some of the strongest materials on earth, but they’re no match for the elements. Ferrous metals start to rust after only a few hours of exposure to air and water. Left unchecked, the orange menace can destroy your car, ruin your tools, and wreak havoc on old plumbing. It will stain your plumbing fixtures, and even your clothes.
Luckily, a spot of rust is not a death sentence for your metal gear. Rust removers use a simple chemical reaction to break down rust, separating it from the surface of metal so you can wipe it away. They come in sprays, gels, and liquids to treat everything from a rusty pair of pliers to a stained toilet bowl. Many of them are non-toxic and environmentally friendly, too. If you aren't sure which rust remover is the right fit for your job, we’ll tell you everything you need to know and recommend a few of our favorites.
Best Rust Removers
- Best Overall: Evapo-Rust ERO12
- Best Value: WD-40 Specialist Rust Remover Soak
- Best Multi-Purpose: Jelmar CLR Pro CL4PROEA Calcium, Lime, and Rust Remover
- Best Heavy-Duty: Corroseal Water-Based Rust Converter
- Best for Kitchens and Bathrooms: Whink Rust Stain Remover
The Expert: I’m a freelance home improvement writer who’s written for Bob Vila, Angi, Futurism, U.S. News and World Report, and Field & Stream, among others. Having spent most of my adult life living in the humidity of the South, I’m intimately familiar with what happens when water and air come into contact with steel. I’ve used rust removal products on everything from tools to concrete pavers, and discovered which ones work and which don’t in the process.
In addition to my own testing and expertise, I relied on insights and expertise from fellow home improvement expert James Fitzgerald, who wrote a previous version of this story.
What to Consider in a Rust Remover
Types of Rust Removers
Chemical rust removers use acid, solvents, or sodium hydrosulfite to dissolve rust off hard surfaces. Depending on the active ingredient, they can be very hazardous: Acid-based rust removers work fast, often dissolving rust in mere minutes, but are so caustic that they may eat through anything but metal, leave permanent etches on stainless steel, and dissolve paint you wish to preserve. Given that, acid chemical rust removers are best limited to removing rust from bare iron and steel.
Sodium hydrosulfite, a more gentle option, requires a longer soaking time, but won’t scar or damage the materials you’re trying to salvage. Rust removers with sodium hydrosulfite typically come in powder form, making them ideal for removing rust from more delicate surfaces, such as concrete, marble, and other types of stone and masonry. It’s also an effective ingredient for removing rust stains from fabrics and porcelain sinks, tubs, and toilets.
Lastly, petroleum-based solvents such as WD-40 penetrate through the rust and loosen it from the surface of the metal, allowing you to wipe it off. As an added benefit, they leave behind a film that helps to prevent rust from returning.
Since they won’t burn your skin or produce harmful fumes, petroleum-based rust removers are also safer to use than acid-based options. That said, we still recommend using eye protection and gloves for any chemical-based option, since they can be harmful if they get in your eyes or under your skin.
Workshop Essentials: Popular Mechanics Tool Awards 2024 • Best Shop Vacs for Cleaning Up Your Garage • Best Power Sanders for Your Shop
Chelating rust removers offer a highly effective, nontoxic, acid-free, and biodegradable solution that binds to iron oxide (A.K.A. rust) and strips it away, making it easy to remove. You typically need to soak your rusty gear in a liquid solution for anywhere from 30 minutes to 24 hours, which gives the agent plenty of time to bind to the rust. There are also gel-based chelating removers, which are helpful for spot-treating rusty areas on toilets, patios, and other surfaces you can’t soak in a tub.
Since chelating removers are non-toxic and acid-free, you can safely use them indoors on a wide range of materials without fear of damaging them or surrounding surfaces. They aren't as powerful as chemical rust removers but are far safer and more convenient.
Rust converters transform rust into a primed, paintable surface, rather than wiping it away, which protects weathered metal from getting rusty again. Converters are typically reserved for treating broad areas that you plan to paint over, such as a trailer, metal fencing, or a vehicle.In most cases, you can either spray or brush the converter onto the rusted surface and allow it to dry without needing to rinse or clean it afterwards, which makes the process less time-consuming and labor-intensive. That said, converters only work on lightly rusted metal, so you may need to scrape or sand thicker layers of rust before applying, depending on the formula.
Form and Application
In addition to checking the active ingredient, keep in mind that rust removers come in a variety of different forms, including liquids, sprays, gels, and powders. Choosing the right form can make your job easier. Choosing wrong will make it feel next to impossible.
Liquid
Most rust removers come in liquid form. Depending on the product, you may need to soak the item in the remover to treat it, or apply it directly to a rust-coated surface and wipe the rust away with a rag or a brush. Liquids are ideal for soaking tools or rusty parts.
Spray
While it won’t penetrate rust as well as a liquid remover, a rust remover spray allows you to apply and treat rust in hard-to-reach places, like inside an engine bay. While this can make a rust remover more convenient and easy to use, spray solutions are typically more expensive than purely liquid varieties, some of which can be used as a spray anyway.
Gel
The thick consistency of gel-based rust remover is particularly useful for spot-cleaning. Unlike a liquid, it clings to materials better than liquids, powders, or sprays, so it’s a good option for removing rust from vertical surfaces. It’s also helpful if you need to get rust stains out of clothing and upholstery.
Powder
Powdered rust removers are often used to remove rust stains from anything near a rusty metal surface, including fabrics, ceramics, and concrete. This type of rust remover is frequently made from sodium hydrosulfite, which can remove rust without damaging delicate materials. Depending on the specific product and intended use, you may either have to apply the remover directly to the stain or mix the powder with water and soak it by submerging the entire item in the solution.
Safety First
You should plan to wear eye protection and gloves when using a rust remover. Depending on what you’re doing, an innocent accident could lead to serious injury if you don’t take proper precautions.
Acid-based rust removers can cause severe burns if they come into contact with your skin or eyes, and they produce fumes that can irritate your throat and lungs.
When using chemical rust removers, especially acid, work in a well-ventilated space and protect yourself with the proper protective equipment, including goggles, gloves, and work clothing to cover any exposed skin.
Less caustic options like chelating removers and rust converters are safer to use, but not completely harmless. In most cases, you should still take basic precautions. I’d recommend wearing gloves and safety glasses of some kind no matter what.
How We Selected the Best Rust Removers
We began our search for the top rust removers by consulting a few experts who deal with rust on a daily basis. Barry Wilson, owner of Wilson Auto Repair in Garland, Texas, drew on 40 years of experience restoring classic cars to make our “best for cars” pick. The Popular Mechanics Test team asked NASA’s Corrosion Technology Laboratory at the Kennedy Space Center to weigh in on our top pick.
For our other selections, we conducted hours of research, evaluating some 20 different rust removal products by comparing specs and reading through dozens of user reviews at online retailers like Home Depot and Amazon. Finally, I also considered my own personal experience with removing rust from toilets, tools, sinks, cars, and all kinds of gear.
Rust removers come in many forms, and are made for many purposes. Our selections reflect that variety, as we made sure to include recommendations for many of the common rust removal jobs the average person faces at home.
Pros
Nontoxic- Multi-purpose
- Fast-acting for a chelating agent
Cons
- May not remove rust stains from plastics or rubber
Evapo-Rust traces the development of its product to its work for America’s military to make a safe, industrial-scale method of rust removal. Evapo-Rust is effective and quick. After six hours of soaking, the testing material used at NASA's laboratory was quite clean. After 12 hours, it was spotless, including the corners and the weld.
In our own testing, we noticed minor carbon deposits had leached out of the steel, but with a little effort we managed to wipe these off using rags and a plastic scouring pad. This isn’t a function of the rust remover as much as it reflects the degree of carbon in the steel or the weld metal. Some steels will emit more carbon in the rust removal process than others. Bottom line: This is a fine and effective product.
Key Specs
| Type | Chelating |
|---|---|
| Form & Application | Liquid soak or direct application |
Best Value
WD-40 Specialist Rust Remover Soak
Pros
- Nontoxic
- No scraping or scrubbing required
- You can use one soak multiple times
Cons
- Useful only on metal
- Long soak time
WD-40 might be most well-known for its lubricating spray, but its specialist formula is an industrial-strength, nontoxic, rust-removing soak capable of stripping off the most stubborn rust at an affordable price.
Best of all, there’s no scrubbing or scraping needed beforehand. Just soak the affected item for the recommended 24-hour period and rinse it off with water. Better still, a single soak can be reused multiple times until it loses its effectiveness, which contributes to its affordability.
Unfortunately, this formula is only useful on metal, so it lacks the multipurpose functionality of some of our other selections. Also, being a chelating agent, it doesn’t work as quickly as many chemical-based formulas.
Key Specs
| Type | Chelating |
|---|---|
| Form & Application | Liquid soak |
Pros
- Fast-acting
- Nontoxic
- Can be used on a variety of surfaces and materials
- Also removes calcium and lime deposits
Cons
- Not as powerful as other options
CLR (Calcium Lime Rust) has been a household staple for decades, and my personal go-to for removing stubborn and unwanted rust. While it’s typically thought of as only a household cleaner, it’s actually an industrial-strength, acid-based solution that can tackle moderate rust formation on a variety of surfaces.
It’s safe to use on metal, brick, and stucco, along with all plumbing materials like copper and PVC plastic. In addition to removing rust, it can also be used to dissolve calcium and lime deposits.
During my last experience using CLR, I used it to remove the rust that had formed on a few of my sockets. Despite having to do some scraping with a wire brush prior to soaking it in the CLR, and having to perform few cycles of soaking and scraping, the sockets I treated were restored to practically pristine condition in a relatively short amount of time.
Key Specs
| Type | Chemical |
|---|---|
| Form & Application | Liquid soak or direct application |
Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below
Pros
- Nontoxic, water-based formula
- Provides future protection against rust formation
- Industrial-strength solution
Cons
When you have a large amount of heavily rusted items to deal with, Corroseal’s rust converter can cover it all with a paintable surface that protects against future rust formation. Although you would expect an industrial-strength formula to be an acid-based solution, Corroseal is completely nontoxic, so you can use it indoors and out.
While it’s technically a rust converter, rather than a rust remover, Corroseal can be used to eliminate the toughest rust that other formulas may not be able to handle. The downside? It’s more expensive than most of our other picks, so you may want to reserve it for the most intractable cases of rust.
Key Specs
| Type | Converter |
|---|---|
| Form | Liquid, direct application |
Pros
- Easy to apply
- No scrubbing required
- Works well on porcelain
Cons
- Doesn’t work well on metal
Having lived in several homes with well water and hard city water, I’ve spent plenty of time battling rust stains in kitchens and bathrooms. This little brown bottle has long been my go-to rust remover on tile and porcelain. It’s easy to apply to sinks, tubs, and toilets, and doesn’t require much effort to wipe off. There’s no need for vigorous scrubbing or hours of soaking.
That said, Whink is a specialized cleaner. It’s great on tile and I’ve used it to clean carpeting, but it isn’t great for getting rust off metal. Also, the hydrofluoric-acid-based formula isn’t safe to touch, so you’ll want to suit up with heavy rubber gloves and wear eye protection when it’s time to clean.
Key Specs
| Type | Acid |
|---|---|
| Form & Application | Direct application |
Pros
- Preps metal for paint
- Zinc phosphate coating chemically bonds to steel
- Easy to apply over large areas
Cons
- Very hazardous: Requires well-ventilated space, mask, gloves, and eye protection
Expert mechanic and car restorer Barry Wilson usually relies on a sand blaster to remove rusty spots when fixing up a classic car, but he relies on POR-15 Metal Prep when the rust is too extensive and might warp the metal. Unlike most acid-based rust removers, POR-15–short for Paint Over Rust–not only melts away rust, but preps the metal underneath for paint by lightly etching the metal and leaving behind a zinc phosphate coating.
The etching gives the paint something to hold on to, and the zinc phosphate chemically bonds the paint to the metal, reducing the chance it will peel off over time. Since you can also apply POR-15 with a brush, roller, or spray, it’s easy to cover a large area. Just make sure you wear a mask and gloves to keep your hands and face safe.
Key Specs
| Type | Acid |
|---|---|
| Form & Application | Liquid direct application or soak |
Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below
Pros
- No scrubbing required
- Nontoxic, eco-friendly formula
- Won’t damage plastic, rubber, or paint
Cons
- Takes a long time to remove rust
You can use elbow grease to scrub corrosion out of the nooks and crannies of your rusty hand tools, or you can just throw them into a Blaster Metal Rescue bath and wait for the rust to melt away. This chelating rust remover gets rid of rust without damaging rubber and plastic grips, or stripping painted markings.
Made with non-toxic ingredients, it’s safe for the environment, and it won’t fill your garage with overpowering fumes. You can also reuse Blaster several times before it loses its rust removing powers. It only ceases to be effective when it turns black.
You’ll need to be patient though, as your rusty tools may need to sit in a Blaster bath overnight for a complete restoration. If you’re not in a time crunch, Blaster is the best and easiest way to get your rusty tools looking like new again.
Key Specs
| Type | Chelating |
|---|---|
| Form & Application | Liquid soak |
Pros
- Works in minutes
- Safe for various materials
- No scrubbing required
Cons
- Not for heavy rust removal
Star-Brite’s rust removal formula is specially designed to remove the rust stains that form on boats, including railings, cleats and other metal parts, but there’s no reason you can’t use it elsewhere. Star Brite can help you effectively wipe rust stains off RVs, house exteriors, toilets, and a whole host of other surfaces.
We like it because it’s safe for a variety of materials, including vinyl, fiberglass, fabric, metal, and painted surfaces. It’s easy to apply, too: Simply spray it on, give it a minute or two to soak in, then wipe off the rust and rinse it clean–No scrubbing required. (Though you may need to add a second application for tougher stains.)
Key Specs
| Type | Oxalic Acid |
|---|---|
| Form & Application | Spray |
Pros
- Concentrated formula makes 2 gallons
- Safe for plastic, rubber and paints
- Can soak for up to 24 hours
Cons
- Requires mixing before use
This concentrated rust remover is a good economic option if you need to soak a rusty rotor, muffler, or some other large car part. Sure, there’s a little prep: You have to dilute it before you can use it. But it’s worth the extra step. A 16-ounce bottle of Rust 911 makes 2 gallons of rust remover, making it by far the most affordable way to remove rust. It’s safe to use around other materials, such as rubber, paint and plastics, while cleaning corrosion from steel, iron, and copper.
Rust 911 removes lighter rust in about 10 minutes, or you can soak parts in it for up to 24 hours for more extensive rust. As with other chelating rust removers, you can use it repeatedly until it turns black. And since it’s non-toxic and environmentally safe, simply pour it down the drain when you’re done.
Key Specs
| Type | Chelating |
|---|---|
| Form & Application | Soak or spray |
Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below
More Rust Removing Tips From Our Experts
How do I protect surfaces from future rust formation after using a rust remover?
To prevent rust from returning on the objects and surfaces that you just treated with a rust remover, you can paint it, apply a corrosion inhibitor, rub on some paste wax, or coat it with a light layer of linseed oil. Using a rust converter instead of a conventional rust remover will also provide an additional layer of protection. You can further minimize the risk of rust returning by preventing or minimizing exposure to oxygen and water.
What materials can rust removers be used on?
The materials a rust remover is suitable for will depend on the type of rust remover it is. Rust removers that use strong acids are usually effective only on metal, while certain chelating rust removers and those primarily composed of sodium hydrosulfite can be used on fabrics, stone, and concrete, but are infrequently effective on most metals.
When should I use a rust converter instead of a regular rust remover?
Since rust converters can simply be applied without having to rinse or wipe off the rust afterwards, it’s usually the ideal solution for covering a large surface area. Since they’re frequently available in spray bottles or aerosol cans, they can also be more useful for applying to hard-to-reach areas that you can’t access by hand.
As a general rule, rust converters are best to use on objects and materials that you will consider painting later on, since they convert the rust into a permeable surface that’s intended for paint.
What’s the best homemade rust remover?
If you prefer home remedies to commercial products, we know a couple of recipes for simple homemade rust removers:
- If you need to clean rust off of tools, car parts, or other small objects, soak them in a tub of vinegar overnight. Don’t leave them submerged for more than 24 hours, as the acidity of the vinegar will eventually start to damage the metal.
- For cleaning rust off garden tools and other objects that are too large to soak, make a paste that consists of one part lemon juice and two parts baking soda. Apply to the rust using a toothbrush and give it about 30 minutes to work its magic, then scrub it off with a sponge.
Keep in mind that, while these homemade methods get the job done, they usually require more elbow grease than a commercial rust remover.
Tony Carrick
Tony Carrick is a full-time freelance writer who specializes in technology, home improvement, DIY, home security, and outdoor recreation. He’s tested and written about everything from home security systems to power tools to gas grills. His product guides, how-to articles, and feature stories can be found in such publications as Bob Vila, Angi, U.S. News and World Report, Field & Stream, Futurism, and Switchful. When Tony isn’t writing, he can be found working on his latest home improvement effort at his home in North Carolina.
